Online Store Butters Store / Butters Sort by We recommend Newest arrivals Price: Low to High Price: High to Low Name: A to Z Name: Z to A Apple Butter 9 oz Apple Butter 9 oz $6.49 Buy Now “Farm Favorite” Apple Butter 18oz Apple Butter 18oz $7.49 Buy Now Apple Butter - Honey Crisp 9 oz Apple Butter - Honey Crisp 9 oz $6.49 Buy Now Apple Butter - Honey Crisp 19 oz Apple Butter - Honey Crisp 19 oz $7.49 Buy Now Pecan Apple Butter 9 oz Pecan Apple Butter 9 oz $6.99 Buy Now Pecan Apple Butter 18 oz Pecan Apple Butter 18 oz $7.99 Buy Now Sweet Potato Butter 18 oz Sweet Potato Butter 18 oz $7.49 Buy Now Pumpkin Butter 9 oz Pumpkin Butter 9 oz $6.49 Buy Now Sold out Peach Butter 9 oz Peach Butter 9 oz $6.49 Out of stock Sold out Peach Butter 18 oz Peach Butter 18 oz $7.49 Out of stock NSA Apple Butter 8oz NSA Apple Butter 8oz $6.49 Buy Now NSA Apple Butter 17 oz NSA Apple Butter 17 oz $7.49 Buy Now